Bless their hearts, the National Guard _______.
Wednesday, March 14th, 2007When I passive-aggressively criticize someone, I say, “S/He’s really [positive adjective], but [insert negative comment here].” When Southerners passive-aggressively criticize someone, they say, “Bless his/her heart, s/he’s [insert negative comment here].”
Early, early, early yesterday morning, the National Guard gave us a lecture on the hurricane’s effects in New Orleans, followed by a tour through the city and a few of the surrounding perishing parishes. Yes, yes, how nice of the National Guard to take us on a tour. No, of course they did not have an agenda that they hoped to co-opt us into buying —
As part of their niceties, they gave us a CD of the slides presented during the pre-tour lecture. A photo of a National Guardswoman holding a crying black child graces the cover of each disc. There actually is some very informative explanations of How Hurricanes Work and How the Levees Were Breached, all of which the media had done a fairly poor job of explaining. On the discs is a plethora of National Guard-As-Hero photos; included elsewhere in our publicity packet are copies of National Guard-issued press releases: Civilian skills prove worth to communities. Operation Teddy Bear distribute smiles. Airman use time off helping residents.
On the actual tour, we saw areas that, one and a half years after Katrina, still are completely devastated and barren. The Major General hosting the tour – quite a character, and I mean that in a positive way – also took us to Jackson Barracks, the National Guard’s base, and showed us how high the waters reached in their own backyards. Throughout the tour, the Major General ardently defended the National Guard’s role during the post-Katrina chaos. Going door to door to discover the living, the dead, the dismembered. Cleaning the toxic sludge the floods left behind. Evacuating the disabled and the elderly. Ordering the disorder and putting to rest the bedlam.
It was made clear that the National Guard did some incredibly difficult work in the days immediately after the hurricane and in the months that followed. That was what we were supposed to hear. I guess now we’re supposed to go back to USC and tell everyone that National Guard Did Their Job, Really and National Guard Received Undeserved Flack for Not Doing Enough Post-Katrina and National Guard Barricades Self from the Poor and the Black at Superdome, but Let’s Look at the Positive Side.
I’m self-conscious about being too critical, because I know the proper thing to do here is to thank the National Guard profusely for being gracious enough as to take the time to give us a guided tour. But, while I am grateful for the opportunity, I am also not about to be used to perpetuate an agenda. The National Guard clearly is on a public relations mission to counteract the slew of negative publicity they received for, among other reasons, the debacles at the Superdome and Convention Center. While this makes sense for them, it doesn’t make sense for us to take it at face value, assume they have no underlying motives, and blindly parrot their message. There is more to this story than what they designed to tell us. There is more to being an advocate than passively accepting what others tell you. There is more, and we of all people ought to pick up on it and deconstruct the truths and half-truths.
Bless their hearts, the National Guard.
tien.
